Atomic Test And Set Of Disk Block: Returned False For Equality [best]

of how this error happens in real systems, or should we continue this sci-fi horror

So why is this a crisis? Because the system expected to be the only writer, but something else changed the block.

Modern drives use 4096-byte (4K) sectors. Legacy software sometimes assumes 512-byte sectors. If you try to perform an atomic test-and-set on a 512-byte chunk that straddles two physical 4K blocks, you aren't testing one atomic unit. You are testing half of block A and half of block B. The disk firmware will return a "false" because the comparison wasn't aligned to its native boundary.

# Read expected value from block 0 dd if=/dev/sdX of=expected.bin bs=512 count=1 of how this error happens in real systems,

ATS is a hardware-offloaded storage primitive. It is part of the , specifically defined under the SCSI T10 standard as the COMPARE AND WRITE command.

The host checks the current metadata of a disk block to see if it matches what it expects.

When the system reports that this operation "returned false for equality," it means the phase failed. Legacy software sometimes assumes 512-byte sectors

To understand why the test-and-set operation fails, it is essential to understand how modern storage virtualization handles file locking.

What or filesystem are you running (e.g., VMware ESXi, KVM, OCFS2)? What is the make and model of your storage array ?

: Frequent LUN reset or ATS failure messages appearing in the vmkernel.log . Potential Resolutions The disk firmware will return a "false" because

To understand why this error occurs, it is essential to first understand how modern clustered file systems, such as VMware's Virtual Machine File System (VMFS), manage concurrency. The Evolution of Storage Locking

The mechanism is often implemented via commands or similar primitives (e.g., NVMe Compare and Write, or Linux’s BLKZEROOUT with verification).

This public link is valid for 7 days and shares a thread, including any personal information you added. This link or copies made by others cannot be deleted. If you share with third parties, their policies apply. Can’t copy the link right now. Try again later.